| Rank | Team | 1895 | 1896 | 1897 | 1898 | 1899 | 1900 | 1901 | 1902 | 1903 | 1904 | 1905 | 1906 | 1907 | 1908 | 1909 | 1910 | 1911 | 1912 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| New York | 1522.0 | 1523.4 | 1498.8 | 1469.7 | 1493.7 | 1441.7 | 1457.8 | 1424.4 | 1458.7 | 1485.3 | 1507.0 | 1440.0 | 1452.0 | 1527.6 | 1516.7 | 1513.7 | 1505.4 | 1509.1 | |
| New York | 1470.8 | 1465.1 | 1527.5 | 1505.1 | 1452.6 | 1444.3 | 1447.1 | 1423.8 | 1372.7 | 1445.6 | 1431.2 | 1448.4 | 1466.8 | 1461.8 | 1446.5 | 1495.0 | 1505.8 | 1511.9 | |
| Brooklyn | 1437.4 | 1507.9 | 1503.4 | 1456.7 | 1480.0 | 1561.7 | 1572.4 | 1617.1 | 1587.8 | 1570.9 | 1593.1 | 1588.2 | 1611.6 | 1591.3 | 1590.5 | 1556.9 | 1583.8 | 1590.9 | |
| Philadelphia | 1554.2 | 1584.1 | 1552.8 | 1583.9 | 1575.6 | 1553.1 | 1518.0 | 1562.5 | 1529.0 | 1557.7 | 1601.7 | 1561.5 | 1508.6 | 1468.2 | 1487.2 | 1493.4 | 1506.2 | 1530.4 | |
| Providence | 1543.4 | 1526.1 | 1504.6 | 1508.9 | 1487.1 | 1437.9 | 1431.4 | 1442.3 | 1560.1 | 1445.5 | 1432.4 | 1485.8 | 1445.1 | 1458.3 | 1483.7 | 1486.3 | 1458.7 | 1411.7 | |
| Boston | 1543.5 | 1518.1 | 1452.9 | 1474.5 | 1484.3 | 1510.5 | 1498.1 | 1494.8 | 1482.3 | 1485.5 | 1479.5 | 1529.6 | 1472.5 | 1452.6 | 1429.8 | 1450.2 | 1489.2 | 1527.7 | |
| Richmond | 1456.2 | 1384.5 | 1442.3 | 1517.9 | 1525.3 | 1534.1 | 1554.5 | 1510.7 | 1574.6 | 1551.2 | 1571.8 | 1527.3 | 1577.5 | 1555.0 | 1539.2 | 1538.3 | 1557.9 | 1521.7 | |
| Baltimore | 1478.5 | 1490.0 | 1512.0 | 1484.4 | 1495.0 | 1519.2 | 1528.5 | 1523.2 | 1435.2 | 1467.2 | 1391.8 | 1419.1 | 1476.7 | 1479.7 | 1507.4 | 1472.6 | 1404.0 | 1402.2 | |
| Saint Louis | 1526.9 | 1496.3 | 1463.7 | 1450.5 | 1470.5 | 1472.7 | 1469.2 | 1478.3 | 1519.4 | 1522.6 | 1510.8 | 1503.6 | 1494.6 | 1527.4 | 1520.2 | 1507.2 | 1562.5 | 1553.4 | |
| Chicago | 1521.8 | 1518.3 | 1492.5 | 1511.3 | 1470.7 | 1482.8 | 1471.8 | 1500.0 | 1478.2 | 1434.8 | 1459.8 | 1448.5 | 1423.5 | 1473.6 | 1361.5 | 1436.2 | 1461.2 | 1501.3 | |
| Saint Louis | 1534.0 | 1496.2 | 1450.0 | 1453.5 | 1480.9 | 1470.3 | 1438.7 | 1498.3 | 1536.8 | 1533.9 | 1545.8 | 1511.9 | 1550.1 | 1506.0 | 1551.3 | 1528.0 | 1524.3 | 1450.5 | |
| Twin City | 1464.8 | 1461.9 | 1507.0 | 1546.3 | 1537.3 | 1533.2 | 1596.2 | 1546.4 | 1512.8 | 1528.7 | 1535.5 | 1541.2 | 1548.0 | 1495.6 | 1514.2 | 1456.0 | 1484.6 | 1449.0 | |
| Cleveland | 1507.3 | 1513.3 | 1559.2 | 1549.0 | 1496.1 | 1508.5 | 1530.6 | 1499.5 | 1504.2 | 1542.5 | 1507.1 | 1558.9 | 1550.9 | 1568.9 | 1553.7 | 1545.3 | 1501.6 | 1511.4 | |
| Chicago | 1533.7 | 1555.3 | 1518.7 | 1490.4 | 1536.7 | 1537.4 | 1497.6 | 1490.2 | 1496.0 | 1462.8 | 1497.0 | 1483.9 | 1465.2 | 1436.7 | 1485.0 | 1434.7 | 1429.8 | 1488.0 | |
| Pittsburgh | 1478.7 | 1433.6 | 1456.1 | 1454.2 | 1438.3 | 1466.3 | 1454.6 | 1478.3 | 1466.1 | 1469.5 | 1437.4 | 1455.1 | 1477.8 | 1508.6 | 1522.9 | 1575.8 | 1571.9 | 1535.0 | |
| Detroit | 1426.9 | 1525.9 | 1558.5 | 1543.6 | 1575.9 | 1526.2 | 1533.5 | 1510.2 | 1486.2 | 1496.3 | 1498.2 | 1497.0 | 1479.0 | 1486.0 | 1489.0 | 1509.8 | 1452.9 | 1505.7 |