| Most Wins over a 3 year span | ||
|---|---|---|
| Player | Years | W |
| Tom Barrell | 1934-1936 | 72 |
| Lefty Allen | 1938-1940 | 71 |
| Sam Sheppard | 1935-1937 | 70 |
| Lefty Allen | 1937-1939 | 70 |
| Rabbit Day | 1936-1938 | 69 |
| Sam Sheppard | 1934-1936 | 67 |
| Roy Calfee | 1929-1931 | 65 |
| Roy Calfee | 1928-1930 | 65 |
| Lefty Allen | 1939-1941 | 65 |
| Tom Barrell | 1933-1935 | 64 |
| Sam Sheppard | 1933-1935 | 64 |
| Lefty Allen | 1936-1938 | 63 |
| Rabbit Day | 1934-1936 | 62 |
| Ed Bowman | 1948-1950 | 61 |
| Ken Carpenter | 1929-1931 | 61 |
| Rabbit Day | 1930-1932 | 60 |
| Don Cannaday | 1926-1928 | 60 |
| Rabbit Day | 1935-1937 | 60 |
| Rabbit Day | 1932-1934 | 60 |
| Ed Wood | 1941-1943 | 59 |