 |
|
|
| League History Index | Players | Teams | Managers | Leagues | Leaderboards | Awards | Accomplishments |
| Rank | Player | WAR | YEAR | Open Season Leaderboard |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Leo McKenzie# | 73.36 | 1895-1916 | |
| 2 | Enrique Johnson# | 60.20 | 1903-1916 | |
| 3 | Golden Reeves# | 59.63 | 1903-1916 | |
| 4 | Ricky McCoy | 50.20 | 1895-1911 | |
| 5 | Celestin Robley# | 46.80 | 1897-1915 | |
| 6 | Phil Winters | 46.31 | 1895-1911 | |
| 7 | Hyman Rickward# | 46.19 | 1904-1916 | |
| 8 | Ignatius Strawson | 43.94 | 1899-1913 | |
| 9 | Kensington Jones | 42.81 | 1895-1909 | |
| 10 | Charlie Taylor# | 42.63 | 1906-1916 | |
| 11 | Leander Witheycombe# | 42.43 | 1906-1916 | |
| 12 | Johnny Hyde | 41.80 | 1895-1912 | |
| 13 | Clovis Juby# | 40.82 | 1901-1915 | |
| 14 | Dom Shearer | 39.59 | 1895-1909 | |
| 15 | Richard Dunkley# | 38.90 | 1901-1916 | |
| 16 | Nicky Williams | 37.85 | 1895-1907 | |
| 17 | Elroy Fowler# | 37.76 | 1905-1916 | |
| 18 | Rocky Poss | 37.44 | 1895-1911 | |
| 19 | Rufus Burnell# | 35.72 | 1899-1915 | |
| 20 | Moriarty Stapleton | 35.08 | 1895-1908 | |
| 21 | Sigurd White# | 35.07 | 1905-1915 | |
| 22 | Zach Pizza | 35.05 | 1895-1910 | |
| 23 | Loyal Wright# | 34.94 | 1903-1916 | |
| 24 | Isaiah Godbolt# | 34.69 | 1906-1916 | |
| 25 | Charles Bird# | 33.78 | 1906-1915 | |
| 26 | Ansel Hawley# | 33.75 | 1903-1916 | |
| 27 | Robbie Salmon | 33.72 | 1895-1908 | |
| 28 | Billy Coats | 33.55 | 1895-1908 | |
| 29 | Dwight Ford# | 33.33 | 1907-1916 | |
| 30 | Mickey McCallister# | 32.48 | 1905-1916 | |
| 31 | Ralph Bennett | 32.25 | 1900-1911 | |
| 32 | Alfred Miller# | 31.58 | 1907-1916 | |
| 33 | Charles Masterson | 31.22 | 1903-1912 | |
| 34 | Al Barnes | 31.16 | 1896-1910 | |
| 35 | Rusty Hall | 31.13 | 1895-1907 | |
| 36 | Nicky Thompson | 30.59 | 1895-1909 | |
| 37 | George Cook# | 30.57 | 1907-1916 | |
| 38 | George Seward | 29.89 | 1904-1913 | |
| 39 | Geoffrey Burrows | 29.82 | 1895-1909 | |
| 40 | Caesar Scott | 29.56 | 1906-1913 | |
| 41 | James Knight# | 29.38 | 1907-1916 | |
| 42 | Wilfred Longworth# | 29.16 | 1901-1916 | |
| 43 | Gardner Thompson# | 29.10 | 1905-1916 | |
| 44 | Carl Mullinger# | 29.01 | 1908-1916 | |
| 45 | Matthew Jakubowski | 28.89 | 1895-1908 | |
| 46 | Fred Ronsell# | 28.88 | 1905-1916 | |
| 47 | Scud Scranton | 28.62 | 1906-1914 | |
| 48 | Frank Lansing | 28.45 | 1895-1909 | |
| 49 | Parker Pettigrew | 28.26 | 1902-1913 | |
| 50 | Demetrius Dwyer | 27.41 | 1895-1908 | |
| 51 | Israel Hunt# | 26.90 | 1903-1914 | |
| 52 | Richmond Elliott# | 26.82 | 1904-1916 | |
| 53 | Tennessee Mears | 26.29 | 1906-1915 | |
| 54 | Jamie Tew | 25.54 | 1895-1909 | |
| 55 | Franz Slaughter# | 25.44 | 1903-1916 | |
| 56 | Mike Sherrod | 25.20 | 1895-1905 | |
| 56 | Estel Bonfield# | 25.20 | 1902-1916 | |
| 58 | Constant Payne# | 24.90 | 1904-1916 | |
| 59 | Caleb Williamson# | 24.68 | 1910-1916 | |
| 60 | George Miller# | 24.27 | 1910-1916 | |
| 61 | Frank Butler# | 23.39 | 1911-1916 | |
| 62 | Ray Faulkner# | 23.26 | 1906-1915 | |
| 63 | Marion Chattaway | 23.13 | 1902-1913 | |
| 64 | Mat Dace | 23.07 | 1895-1905 | |
| 65 | Laurence Fox# | 22.81 | 1906-1916 | |
| 66 | Theodore Hill | 22.71 | 1900-1912 | |
| 67 | Harland Gunton | 22.67 | 1896-1910 | |
| 68 | Mick Samuelson | 22.36 | 1895-1903 | |
| 69 | Van Turner | 22.11 | 1902-1914 | |
| 70 | Oscar Fargus | 21.92 | 1903-1910 | |
| 71 | Alfred Gilling | 21.55 | 1901-1910 | |
| 72 | Mike Melin | 21.43 | 1895-1904 | |
| 73 | Selmer Dillamore# | 21.18 | 1909-1916 | |
| 74 | Charles Dixon# | 20.83 | 1908-1916 | |
| 75 | Randy Sliger | 20.77 | 1895-1910 | |
| 76 | Harry Holmes | 20.69 | 1901-1912 | |
| 77 | Gary Johnson | 20.43 | 1895-1912 | |
| 78 | Greenie Redgate# | 19.78 | 1910-1915 | |
| 79 | Lionel Lyon | 19.77 | 1899-1907 | |
| 80 | Mike Thompson | 19.70 | 1896-1911 | |
| 81 | Jacob Kalberer | 19.59 | 1895-1910 | |
| 82 | Mike Lerner | 19.46 | 1895-1905 | |
| 83 | Thomas Dixon | 18.46 | 1897-1913 | |
| 84 | Joseph Bumble | 18.40 | 1903-1915 | |
| 85 | Ed McKee | 18.39 | 1895-1906 | |
| 86 | Calvin Culliford# | 18.29 | 1912-1916 | |
| 87 | Dillard Howard# | 18.25 | 1912-1916 | |
| 87 | Vernon German# | 18.25 | 1906-1915 | |
| 89 | William Marriott | 18.17 | 1901-1914 | |
| 90 | Peter Senhouse# | 18.02 | 1910-1916 | |
| 91 | Earl Secombe# | 18.00 | 1905-1916 | |
| 92 | Madison Allighan | 17.91 | 1903-1914 | |
| 93 | Joel Leonard | 17.69 | 1895-1910 | |
| 94 | Elmer Lawrence# | 17.68 | 1910-1916 | |
| 95 | Adrian Ives# | 17.63 | 1911-1916 | |
| 96 | John Dabney# | 17.38 | 1907-1916 | |
| 97 | Tommy Saline | 17.32 | 1895-1910 | |
| 98 | Anderson Bosshart | 17.26 | 1895-1908 | |
| 99 | Avery Bell# | 17.20 | 1911-1916 | |
| 100 | Laurence Witt# | 17.17 | 1905-1916 |
